James Hannack of Punch & Associates Investment Management presented his investment thesis on Cavco Industries (US: CVCO) at Best Ideas 2026.
Thesis summary:
Cavco is a leading producer of manufactured and modular homes in North America, operating through 33 manufacturing plants and 99 company-owned retail stores. James notes that the industry has undergone substantial consolidation since the Great Recession, evolving from a fragmented landscape into a disciplined oligopoly where the top three players control 85% of the market. This rationalized structure has enabled stable pricing and margins despite volume fluctuations. James highlights that CVCO is particularly well-positioned to consolidate the remaining 15% of the market, as its primary competitor, Clayton, is limited by its existing 50% market share and another peer is undergoing a management transition.
The investment thesis centers on a favorable post-pandemic normalization and the acute shortage of affordable housing. While demand outstripped supply by 50% in FY 2022, constraints have eased, allowing for improved utilization. Manufactured housing represents a viable solution to the national shortage of 3.5 million homes, with HUD-Code units offering an ASP of approximately $85,000—a fraction of the cost of traditional site-built homes. James expects demand to be further supported by real wage growth among lower-end consumers and a stabilization of orders from the REIT and community channels.
Improving regulatory conditions and financing access provide additional tailwinds for the business. James points to recent legislative wins in Texas and New York that mandate more inclusive zoning for HUD-Code homes, effectively lowering barriers to entry in previously restricted municipalities. On the federal level, the industry is gaining visibility in Congress, and there is an ongoing push for GSE participation in the chattel loan market. James believes that involving GSEs would lower interest rates for the roughly one-third of CVCO customers who utilize personal property loans, thereby improving overall housing accessibility.
James identifies a path for the company to double its housing EBIT over the next four years by increasing annual shipments from 20,000 to 30,000 units. This growth is expected to come from restoring plant utilization to 85%, integrating the American Homestar acquisition, and pursuing further organic and inorganic capacity investments. Under the leadership of Bill, who joined the board in 2008 and became CEO in 2019, the company has maintained a fortress balance sheet and a disciplined capital allocation strategy. This approach includes programmatic share repurchases that have reduced the share count by 14% and strategic M&A that adds capacity without disrupting industry supply.
The shares recently traded at a P/E of 28x, justified by CVCO’s high-quality operations and improving ROIC. While the valuation is not optically cheap compared to smaller, less-scaled peers, James sees ~120% upside over a four-year horizon. This assumes EPS reaches $54 through a combination of 400bps in OPM expansion and high incremental margins. The downside is estimated at $280 per share, based on a trough multiple of 2.0x book value, resulting in a favorable 2:1 up-down ratio.
Disclaimer
Best Ideas 2026 was held from January 6-23, 2026. The content of this website is not an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security. The content is distributed for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice or a recommendation to sell or buy any security or other investment, or undertake any investment strategy. There are no warranties, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy, completeness, or results obtained from any information set forth on this website. BeyondProxy’s officers, directors, employees, and/or contributing authors may have positions in and may, from time to time, make purchases or sales of the securities or other investments discussed or evaluated herein.
Slides
Let’s take a closer look.
