Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Industry Primers Podcast: North American Railroads, Part One: The Story

The story of North America’s freight railroads, from the last spike of the Canadian Pacific in 1885 to the builders who sold, merged and rebuilt the networks of Canada, the United States and Mexico, told for anyone.

This is Part One of the Industry Primers audio program on the North American railroads, published by Latticework from MOI Global. It is the first of two audio programs that accompany the written primer on the industry, and it is the story of the industry, told for a general audience. The account is built from documented scenes, with the people named, the dates given, and the participants quoted in their own words, many of them from the long recorded interviews of the National Railroad Hall of Fame, from their letters and memoirs, and from the biographies written by those who knew them. It assumes no background in railroading or finance and explains its terms, from a ton-mile and a short line to the operating ratio, a concession and precision scheduled railroading, as they arrive. This episode is public.

The program runs from the Canadian Pacific’s last spike in the Eagle Pass of British Columbia in November 1885 to the creation of Canadian Pacific Kansas City in April 2023, and from Montreal, St. Paul and Omaha to Houston, Kansas City, Calgary and Mexico City. Its people are the builders of the industry: James J. Hill, who built the Great Northern on the lowest grades he could find, and E. H. Harriman, who rebuilt the Union Pacific; Hays Watkins and John Snow, who brought a railroad company to support deregulation; Rob Krebs, who turned a conglomerate back into a railroad and assembled BNSF; Mike Haverty, who made a trucker his partner and took Kansas City Southern into Mexico; Paul Tellier, who sold Canadian National to the public; and Hunter Harrison and Keith Creel, who remade CN and Canadian Pacific and joined it to Kansas City Southern. It follows how a business left bankrupt and regulated by 1980 was rebuilt by the people who were given the freedom to set its prices.

Part One stands on its own. It tells how the networks took their present shape, from the transcontinental lines to the mergers that left two railroads in each half of the United States and the first railroad across all three countries. The economics of the business, and the companies as investments, are the subject of Part Two and of the written primer. The records it gives are total returns with dividends reinvested, each stated with its window and its benchmark.

The program runs in eighteen sections:

  1. Full Fare. At about 9 a.m. on November 7, 1885, in the Eagle Pass of British Columbia, Donald Smith drives an ordinary iron spike to finish the Canadian Pacific, which William Cornelius Van Horne had built in less than 5 of the 10 years the government’s contract allowed, and the first scheduled transcontinental train leaves Montreal on June 28, 1886.

  2. The Best Possible Line. After the Union Pacific and the Central Pacific meet at Promontory Summit on May 10, 1869, James J. Hill orders “the best possible line, shortest distance, lowest grades, and least curvature” for the Great Northern, which reaches the Pacific without a federal land grant and, in the year to June 1894, cuts its rate 11 percent and still pays its usual dividend.

  3. A Thousand Dollars a Share. E. H. Harriman rides the reorganized Union Pacific to the Pacific in 1898 and rebuilds it, and in May 1901 his fight with Hill for the Burlington corners the Northern Pacific’s common stock at US$1,000 a share, before the Supreme Court breaks up Northern Securities, five votes to four, on March 14, 1904.

  4. Too Big to Fail. Hays Watkins of the Chesapeake and Ohio sees early in 1970 that Penn Central can no longer place its commercial paper, the railroad files for reorganization on June 21, 1970, 28 months after its merger, and on April 1, 1976 Conrail, a railroad created by the federal government, takes over the lines of 6 bankrupt railroads.

  5. I Vote with John. John Snow, the young official who had worked on the Department of Transportation’s proposals to deregulate the railroads, joins Watkins’s Chessie System, Watkins votes with him against most of his officers to support the bill, and President Carter signs the Staggers Rail Act on October 14, 1980, after an industry return of 2.7 percent on net investment in 1979.

  6. Fifteen Hundred Dollars a Car. Rob Krebs, who joined the Southern Pacific in 1966, clears the jammed yards of Houston in 1980, and under the new freedom to sign contracts a car of automobiles from St. Louis to Los Angeles that had paid about US$6,000 under the old tariff moves for US$1,500.

  7. Cold Hard Cash. After the commission turns down the Santa Fe-Southern Pacific merger, Santa Fe Southern Pacific, by Krebs’s account, borrows to pay its shareholders a dividend of US$4.2bn, sells its other businesses and auctions the Southern Pacific to Philip Anschutz’s Rio Grande Industries for about US$1.02bn on October 13, 1988.

  8. I’m J.B. Hunt. Mike Haverty, a conductor’s son from Atchison, becomes the Santa Fe’s president in 1989, and on November 1, 1989 takes J.B. Hunt on an intermodal train out of Chicago, beginning a partnership whose revenue, by Haverty’s count, grew from about US$30m to about US$1.5bn by 2018.

  9. Green and Orange. Krebs agrees on June 30, 1994 to merge the Santa Fe with Burlington Northern, outlasts Union Pacific’s rival bid until it withdraws on January 31, 1995, and paints 500 new locomotives in the Great Northern’s green and orange, while CSX and Norfolk Southern divide Conrail, 42 percent and 58 percent.

  10. Give Me a Good Board. Paul Tellier, a lawyer and Clerk of the Privy Council who had never worked for a railroad, takes over Canadian National on October 1, 1992 on condition that he may privatize it, and by his account abolishes 6 vice-presidents’ posts on his first day and closes the executive dining room.

  11. Not the B Team. Tellier tells Goldman Sachs “I want your best team. I don’t want the B team,” takes the offering on the road with his wife beside him, and on November 17, 1995 the government of Canada sells the whole of CN at C$27 a share.

  12. Two Dollars an Hour. Hunter Harrison starts in the Frisco’s Memphis yard at the end of 1963 for US$2 an hour, works under Ed Moyers at the Illinois Central the Prospect Group took private in 1989, and as its chief executive from 1993 takes its operating ratio from 68.2 percent to 62.3 percent in 1997 on the same track.

  13. Part of the Assets. On February 10, 1998, after talks settled in the dark of the Quebec ice storm, CN agrees to pay US$39 a share for Illinois Central, about US$2.4bn for the shares, keeps Harrison as “part of the assets”, and from late 1996 to the end of 2002 its holders make about 2.5 times their money against about 1.25 times for the S&P 500.

  14. Expanding into Mexico. Haverty takes the Kansas City Southern job in May 1995 on condition that the board consider Mexico, and in December 1996 Kansas City Southern and TMM win 80 percent of Mexico’s Northeast line for about MXN 11.07bn, about US$1.4bn, which begins operating on June 23, 1997.

  15. The Stilwell Dream. Kansas City Southern spins off its financial businesses as Stilwell Financial on July 12, 2000, takes full control of its Mexican railroad in 2005, and US$1,000 put into it at the end of 2000 becomes about US$4,700 by the end of 2010, against about US$1,150 in the S&P 500.

  16. An All-In Wager. BNSF and CN announce their merger on December 20, 1999, the regulator imposes a 15-month moratorium on major mergers on March 17, 2000 and in June 2001 writes rules that require a merger to enhance competition, and Berkshire Hathaway agrees on November 3, 2009 to acquire the 77.4 percent of BNSF it does not already own at US$100 a share.

  17. Worst to First. As CN’s chief executive from 2003, Harrison takes its operating ratio to 60.7 percent in 2006 and US$1,000 in CN grows to about US$4,400 by the end of 2009; after Pershing Square wins its proxy contest on May 17, 2012, he takes Canadian Pacific’s ratio from 81.3 percent in 2011 to 58.6 percent in 2016, then goes on to CSX, his fourth railroad.

  18. Three Countries. Keith Creel, chief executive of Canadian Pacific from January 31, 2017, follows his board’s mandate to grow, wins Kansas City Southern in September 2021 after the regulator rejects CN’s voting trust, and on April 14, 2023 creates Canadian Pacific Kansas City, the only railroad with one line through Canada, the United States and Mexico.

The program runs 1 hour 31 minutes (1:30:56). The written primer, Industry Primer: North American Railroads, and its companion deck are on the Latticework Substack at the Industry Primer on North American railroads. Part Two, the deep dive for professional investors, is a separate episode, available to members of Latticework: Industry Primers Podcast: North American Railroads, Part Two: The Deep Dive.


This audio program is published by MOI Global for educational purposes only. It is not investment advice, an offer, or a solicitation, and no security mentioned herein is recommended for purchase or sale. The publisher and contributors may hold positions in securities discussed. Figures are believed accurate as of the dates stated but are not warranted; listeners should verify all data against primary sources before relying on it. Nothing herein constitutes legal, tax, or accounting advice.


Transcript

The transcript is available for download to members only.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?